23/05/2013 17:32
chart
EUR / Venemaa rubla
40.4890
EUR / USA dollar
1.2888
EUR / Rootsi kroon
8.5943
EUR / Läti latt
0.7005
Baltic temperature
  Up11.76%
  Freeze23.53%
  Down64.71%
Winners and losers
JRV1T +0.35%
PRF1T +0.14%
VSN1T-5.31%
EEG1T-2.68%
ARC1T-2.65%
Turnover TOP
TAL1T475879.94
TVEAT274713.70
OEG1T153699.97
TKM1T46760.74
BLT1T43306.89
SFGAT35408.34
EEG1T12536.91
Exchange rates
Leedu litt3.4528 +0.00%
USA dollar1.2888 +0.00%
Rootsi kroon8.5943 +0.00%
Läti latt0.7005 +0.00%
Databases of Estonian companies
Back
Text size AAA Print

Estonia ranked No. 1 in the world by Internet freedom

THIS PUBLICATION HAS 5 COMMENTS
ADD YOUR COMMENT
Here's the full report:

http://www.freedomhouse.org/sites/default/files/FOTN%202012%20summary%20of%20findings.pdf

There is a slight reliability problem with this study as the analysts for the reports on Estonia and some other countries "are
independent internet researchers who have requested to remain anonymous."

In other words, the results of the reearchers for these countries can not be verified and aligned to their possible interests attached, and are therefore to be taken with a pinch of salt.

Some of the restriction of internet freedom in Estonia coming to my mind is the access blocking of foreign online casinos sites by the Tax & Customs Board and the intervention on content of DELFI and other online media outlets by the Defense Police Board.

Also worth to mention about is the violations of user rights, which some of them you may reviw even on this site at given times. Reply to the comment answer
~knut albers [25.09.2012, 12:54]
The weakness in this report is that Estonia does censor the internet. If you are in Estonia, and you try to go to an online gambling site that does not have a gaming license for Estonia, then you get redirected to a the Estonian Tax authority's webpage instead.

In other words, the government has provided a list of blocked sites to all internet providers, and they block access to it. No country that blocks access to _any_ content should rank #1 on this list.

This is a slippery slope -- the mechanism is in place and the Estonian government can now easily ask providers to censor any other content they don't like.

By comparison, in the US, this practice is not followed. Even though online gambling sites are not legal in the US, you can still go to the sites. Instead, they block the funding of such activities, as credit card companies won't let you use the cards to spend at gambling sites.

One article I read said the main reason the US did not get #1 is that high-speed internet access is expensive or impossible to obtain in rural areas of the country. This is true, and there are plans to improve this. It's simply a very costly endeavor due to the country's size.
~ameeriklane [25.09.2012, 15:13]
The worst thing is that this type of censorship is meaningless, as this so called "access blocking" by manipulating DNS entries can be bypassed with ease through proxies, vpn, freenet, you name it.

Unless one would implement deep package inspection (which would Estonia let plump instantly in the ranks of Syria, Bahrain and China), all it does is leaving a bitter taste on internet freedom without the wanted benefits on it.

They tried the same in Germany by blocking websites that contain child pornography (like they already do in Australia, Sweden and the UK, for instance, where strange to say somehow again and again are websites blocked nothing to do with it), what sounds at first like a heroic act.

The thing is that this doesn't dry out such criminal milieus, but just "blackens" the black holes of the internet where such sick stuff is hosted on (well known St. Petersburg and the Netherlands to be some of the places, as F-Secure and other labs of security software found out last year), just like Iran is blacken every infamous magazine imported to their country (by handicraft with eddings, btw).

If one wants to fight the worst crimes in this world and money laundering, it is not necessary to do this with help of censorship.

We just need to dry up the profiteers financially, by disconnecting them from the money supply and maybe someone should impose to investigate certain data centers in the Netherlands, for instance, where most of online gambling sites worldwide are hosted also.
~knut albers [25.09.2012, 15:48]
rate it
answer
Reply to the comment
What is there to censor in Estonia. Very dull gray country that never achieves anything significant outside Skype. Reply to the comment answer
~eesti celebrity [25.09.2012, 14:14]
rate it
answer
Reply to the comment
Internetfreedom doesn´t mean informationfreedom in the case, that the people here are fully informated about, what is up in the world. They are mostly only bordered to their own "narcism" and stick to this. This means, everything informativ, what plays outside of Estonia doesn´t reach their minds. Tragical. Reply to the comment answer
~scheileke [26.09.2012, 01:49]
rate it
answer
Reply to the comment
Main news
Latest blog posts
Legal Blog from TRINITI
Legal Blog from TRINITI
Legal Blog from TRINITI