A little under four years ago Marnus Labuschagne was the world’s top-ranked Test batter, having averaged 60.82 across his first 30 matches for Australia.
What happened next remains one of cricket’s great mysteries, with the Queenslander’s career now at a crossroads — to put it mildly — and the axe again hovering.
Labuschagne was not alone in disappointing on what was Australia’s worst day of cricket this decade against South Africa on Wednesday.
Know the news with the 7NEWS app: Download today
But his outing was the most frustrating, as the tourists were all out for 99 and then 4-156 at stumps on Day 4 after being asked to follow on, still trailing by 170 runs.
After being superbly caught in the first innings for 14, the 32-year-old acted like a man who knew his career was on the line during his second dig later in the day.
He nailed down, did the hard work, was as relieved as anyone when he overturned an lbw review by 4.7 millimetres on review and again got his way into the 30s.
Then he tried to take on spinner Simon Harmer into a howling wind and was caught at a deep mid-on for 39.
When Labuschagne hit the 10th career century against West Indies at Adelaide Oval in December 2022, they had come in his first 51 innings as a Test player.
In the 69 innings since, he has hit just one, with that coming against England in the 2023 Ashes some 26 Tests ago.
His average since December 2022 is less than half what it was, now 29.29 across that time.
Australia have made no secret of the fact Labuschagne needs a big score, but tellingly six of his last nine scores have now been between 30 and 49.
The critics have come and come hard.
When he lost his wicket against South Africa with his skied drive, former Australian opener Simon Katich said: “What the hell is that?”
He continued: “How many players in the history of Australian cricket have been given this many opportunities without scoring a hundred?
“Back in the day, you were lucky if you didn’t get dropped after missing 10 times.
“He can hang his head backwards and think he’s unlucky, but you’re trying to hang on for a draw and you try and go downtown into the breeze after getting a reprieve, you have to wonder what’s going through his mind.
“And it’s not like it’s a one-off. This has been going on for three years.”
Veteran SEN commentator Gerard Whateley called Labuschagne’s shot “complete and utter madness”.
He added: “He really does get lost in this Bermuda Triangle … That is just daft cricket.
“I just think if Australia was to lose this Test match, he has to be dropped now. Just as a matter of principal.”
Social media account Troll cricket unlimitedd said it should “be a career-ending shot for Marnus Labuschagne”.
“Marnus Labuschagne had a brain fade and assessed the situation horribly here. Very poor from him. He rode his luck throughout his innings and should’ve cashed in. Instead, he is the reason why Australia are staring down the barrel.
“47 innings now without a test 100 and 14 innings without a top 50. This is as a No.3 batter. One of the most pivotal spots in Test cricket. This is simply unacceptable.”
But Australia coach Andrew McDonald defended the veteran.
“He did a lot of hard work once again,” McDonald said.
“It feels like I’m on repeat around the number of 30s that he has got. You would say that’s a danger period for him.
“But when you do that hard work, you’ve got to cash in and unfortunately that wasn’t the case for Marn.
“He’d be disappointed, we’re disappointed and we find ourselves in this situation.”
Whether Labuschagne survives the axe to play in Cape Town next week remains to be seen. He was dropped last year for the three-match West Indies series, but returned three Tests later.
Nic Maddinson appears almost certain to go, while Beau Webster’s returns are also below par.
Cameron Green and Josh Inglis are fit again, while Cooper Connolly and Sam Harper are also on tour.
The fallout from Wednesday will be vast, but Australia must pick a side to win in Cape Town and take victory in the series.
McDonald would not discuss that situation midway through a Test, adamant he didn’t want to “hang players out to dry”.
But big conversations and decisions do loom for the coach and fellow selectors in coming days.
– With 7NEWS.com.au
